Sunday at the table... The Republic and Plato's Philosopher Kings
Here I sit, Sunday at 10:39 CST Ti PowerBook next to the kitchen window and a double espresso at my right hand. (Oh yeah, and RadioStorm streaming through iTunes. As I was making this morning's brew, I sat there wondering (waiting for the boiler on the dying Delonghi to heat up) what makes a person wish to live in a socialistic (read: communist) society? I really wonder about these types of things. Is it the humanistic altruism they think socialism is supposedly made of? Is it that they feel everyone should be given what everyone else has - i.e. there should be no differences in the material wealth of each individual? My questions are aimed at understanding the psychological draw that socialism has on people. I am almost convinced that those who support a system by which individual freedoms are trumped by the wishes of a dictator, monarch or beaurocracy must have psychological reasonings for their desires. What would make me sit back and wish upon myself a system by which my own decisions to do with my skills are relegated to the back seat because someone else has a grander and more noble plan? I remember when I read Plato's The Republic being completely taken by his argument that society would best be maintained by the Philosopher Kings. It was only as I read further (i.e. more philosophy) and grew older and more experienced (in working and learning), that I realized that Plato's vision was nothing more than a means of suggesting that someone else knows better than I what is good for me. This is the point that I find so confusing whenever someone begins to expound upon how society would be better off if we were to leave the "big" decisions up to the experts. What this boils down to, however, is that the succession of decision ends up in the hands of someone so far removed from the situation that the best decision is not made. How is this type of decision making better for me or for society?
Continue reading "Sunday at the table... The Republic and Plato's Philosopher Kings" »
